Feedback Between Two Final Front Cover Designs

Magazine One

 Magazine Two

I have had a hard decision deciding whether to keep the two pugs saying "Tyga" and "Trey Songz" as I wasn't sure if they are necessary and make the page look too overcrowded. However without them I wasn't sure if the page looked too plain, but after analysing a number of R&B magazines, I found simplicity was a trend. 

Therefore I decided to ask for feedback on the two magazine front covers and to see what potential R&B magazine buyers would prefer. The question I proposed to every person was: 

I then sent them a picture of both magazome front covers. The feedback I recieved was:

Jess, aged 17

Chloe, aged 17 

Amber, aged 16 

Caitlin, aged 17 

Myles, aged 16

Frank, aged 16

My feedback has shown that magazine 1 defnitely proves to be the most popular and people don't find the page to be overcrowded.